Showing posts with label Paul Jay. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Paul Jay. Show all posts

Wednesday, September 09, 2009

Defending Van Jones Would Be a Bad Idea



Barack Obama is not a communist. And because Barack Obama is not a communist, he's obligated to defend an advisor who was prepared to use his office as a means of incrementally implimenting communism.

If one applies their critical thinking skills to Paul Jay's interview with Democrat Donna Edwards on The Real News network, this is a theme that quickly emerges.

In the video, Jay and Edwards commiserate over Barack Obama's failure to defend Van Jones, his Green Jobs csar who recently resigned after a media campaign by FOX News personality Glenn Beck.

"I think that it demonstrates that the opponents to President Obama and to the kind of change he promised to deliver for the American people are relentless," Edwards complained. "The fact that they went after Van Jones is just another demonstration of that."

"This administration, and as we as progressives, can't be sidelined and sidetracked by people who are attacking folks in the administration for things they said before they were appointed into their offices," Edwards continued. "I think it's actually been a real shame."

For her own part, Edwards blames evil corporations.

"The reality that the corporate interests were so opposed to what he's trying to do around energy and the President's agenda around energy reform, that's why they went after him," Edwards explained. "They would have found any reason to go after Van Jones or after anyone else because they don't like the President's energy agenda."

Of course it doesn't help Edwards one bit that Jones very much was the architect of his own discredit.

No one held a gun to Van Jones' head and forced him to gush about the green movement as an incrementalist agenda toward communism.

In her own way, Edwards is right to note similarities between how individuals like Glenn Beck (and there are, no doubt, some strains of lunacy within his own comments about Jones) and others went after Obama and how they went after Jones.

The problem for Edwards is that, as it regards Jones, they were very much accurate.

Despite what individuals like Glenn Beck have to say about him, Barack Obama is far from a political radical or a communist. So for Obama to pull out all the stops from someone who has described himself as both a political radical and a communist (with a potential 9/11 "truth"er thrown in to boot) would probably be about the most foolish thing he could do. He would, in fact, be playing directly into the hands of people like Sean Hannity.

This is all aside from the fact that Van Jones clearly hasn't been entirely earnest with his intentions in regard to the Green Jobs program.

Perhaps Van Jones is the hill that Donna Edwards would like to die on, but Barack Obama is not obligated to charge off into that particular battle.

Friday, April 17, 2009

Real News Has Issues With Reality



When the Conservative party won the 2008 federal election many opponents of the party were disheartened. Others, like Murray Dobbin, were militarized.

Within days Murray Dobbin was on the Real News suggesting that the formation of a coalition government was imminent. As it stood, his prediction was off by a couple of months.

In a recent interview with Liberal party foreign affairs critic Bob Rae, Paul Jay asks him about Michael Ignatieff's abandonment of the Liberal/NDP coalition proposal, noting that it "had quite a bit of support in Canada".

When one calls their network the Real News, one should accept that this level of pretension comes with an obligation that their coverage will closely resemble reality. On this particular occasion, Jay's commentary doesn't.

Polls taken shortly after the formation of the Liberal/NDP coalition, polls revealed that 60% of Canadians opposed the coalition, as opposed to a comparably mere 37% of Canadians that supported it.

Moreover, the Conservative party enjoyed a surge in support after the proposal. Some polls had the Tories polling close to the 50% range.

The consensus among Canadians was clear: if the governing Conservatives were to be defeated, Canadians wanted the opportunity to decide who would govern the country in an election, as opposed to allowing the Liberals and NDP to seize power with a coaltion government that then-leader Stephane Dion had already insisted would never happen.

As a supporter of the Coalition government, Bob Rae certainly cannot afford to admit the extent to which Canadians rejected the proposed coaliton. But deep down, even Rae knows this is true.

Oddly enough, Paul Jay doesn't. This is rather unfortunate from someone who pretends to present the "real" news.